Ideas from Partyzan

Hi guys, i have many ideas and questions about this mod, but i don't know to write it to correct topic and lazy to look if it was written  :P.
so there it is:

1. i don't really see any historical accuracy in add IS-3. Yes it was made before 9Th May 1945 and takes to the Red Army, but IS-3 never sees action in WWII.
So i think that u could remove it and maybe u can make reward units BT-7 and T-26 (one button, like KVs) for T-70 and SU-76 (i think u want BA-64 as reward unit for T-90) because they were fight in first 2 years of the Great patriotic war.

T-26
- upgrade.: flamethrower

BT-7
- upgrade.: BT-7A - 76mm howitzer

2. sorry but i am little bit bored from that u remove movable Flak 38, PAK 36 and PzB 39 (or 38)  :'( . i know it was must be removed in the name of balance. but u could maybe take Flak and PAK 36 to Reward units for OH, or PAK 36 could be moved to Forward HQ

3. there is some ideas for foreign units

Infantry

Italians
-4 men with 4 Mannlicher-Carcano
after modernisation-upgr. to 4x Beretta
u can use some models from 1949 mod

ROA
-4 men with 4 SVT-40
after modernisation - upgr. to 4x PPSH (but with Box Magazine)
u can use some models from 1949 mod

Slovaks
-MG team with ZB vz.37

Romanians
-czech 37mm KPÚV vz.34 (Kanón proti útočné vozbě, Cannon againts assault vehicles)

Hungarians (Honvéd)
-4 troops with MP-40s


Tanks

ROA
- T-34 or KV-1

Italians
-Semovente 75/18

Hungarians
- 43M Zrínyi assault gun

Slovakia - Rychlá divize
- LT-38 or OA vz. 30

Romanians
-Renault (reskinned Hotchkiss)

4. Branderburgers could have russian uniforms,specialy NKVD uniforms( see films ,,Brest Fortress´´and ,,Last armoured train´´). And please,keep the Branderburgers alive as u keep alive Penal military battalions. ;)

5. Those Jaegers are aka Gebirgsjägers? ( because truly never exist in WH some units of ,,Jaegers´´)
Those Jaegers will all of them have Sniper rifles? Is not that OP? :P

6. Are u sure that buildable Panzerwerfer and buildable Brummbär are not OP? ::)

7. I think that Marksmans rifle was only prototype, no? Yes germans were testing StG-44 as scoped rifle, but it was failure (but wait, i love that marksman with that Mkb.42, iam only not sure if it is historical accuracy ;) )

So, developers, u can write ur opinion about this ideas and please dont be angry to me for this.

P.S: Sory for my bad english

I think those ideas have been proposed before. :-\

Thanks for writing your suggestions on our forum, but we don't have plans to add more reward units to soviets for now(or at least not these units), let alone that we are not removing any unit from the current layout as well... regardless of historic accuracy. I'm not going to write once more the same essay to explain why we added it or going to quote the author who said they were used in few numbers nor post a link from a site who says than they were many of them(although not mass produced) before June of 1945, I've done it too many times ;D.

We already decided which units were going to be used and we cannot change them, and just beside some exceptions (that we keep as secret in the Dev board ;)), it has been a while since we passed away the return point for this decision than we don't remember how it looked like :P.

I don't think the PaK 36 has a place in Ostheer. PaK36 and PaK40 are mutually exclusive because you cannot use one to replace the other... you cannot add one pak that early and if you nerf it too much will become useless and you cannot make the pak40 appear too late because it won't be used at all. PaK36 would be like US 57mm atg which has the same role than the pak40 but different stats. So they cannot be used together and I don't think would be worth as reward unit.

AFAIK, all the stats can be tweaked, so there is no reason an unit that seems powerful is automatically OP. That's why we have balancers.

Atm of the Ostheer layout is already defined, the same for the foreign units, we've decided which units we would need for them, in that way Burro could finish them in the past ;). (Btw, the Semovente 75/18 wasn't used in the Eastern Front)

Now, concerning your topic's location, there are already topics opened regarding this and are precisely located at the Red Army Suggestions and the Ostheer Suggestions. So, as I cannot split this into two topics, I'll lock it.

Last edited April 27, 2012 at 8:51 PM by blackbishop