EFEastern Front Forum Archive
Read-only public archive · no login or tracking

Locked topic · 31 posts

Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Eastern Front

Archived poll

What was the best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Kar98k20 votes · 59%
Lee-Enfield 8 votes · 24%
Springfield 19032 votes · 6%
Arisaka Type 380 votes · 0%
Mosin-Nagant3 votes · 9%
MAS-360 votes · 0%
Carcano 0 votes · 0%
Hanyang 880 votes · 0%
Other1 votes · 3%

34 total votes

#40445

Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Hey guys, I'm back with another poll! This time with Bolt-Action Rifles. I would like to give credit to HyperSniper999, he's the one who came up with the poll "Best Rifle of World War 2?" I have voted in his poll, and was kind of disappointed in how he mixed Semi-Automatic and Bolt-Actions together. Mostly everybody voted for the M1 Garand as it was Semi-Automatic, mass-produced, and the first of its kind to be standard issue for an entire nation's infantry. The Second World War was practically mostly fought with Bolt-Actions. It wouldn't make sense
comparing these two types. It's like comparing a Smooth bore Musket with an Rifled Musket. Below I am going to list some history and stats on the weapons, because I've actually fired some of them(they're surprisingly not that expensive). Have fun, and remember I am giving the credit of the first rifle poll to HyperSniper999, I am creating this poll for the sole purpose of comparing my favorite type of firearms! If you have any problems, please notify me below.

Post Merge: [time]1278998843[/time]

OK, here we go...

Kar98k: A shortened version of the Gewehr 98, which was used by the forces of Germany in the First World War. It was the icon of the new series of Bolt-Actions, using smokeless powder,the Mauser System, and stripper clips. Very well balanced rifle, with good power, range, and handling. Uses a 5 round internal magazine. Fires the 7.92x57mm Mauser.

Lee-Enfield: Adopted by the British in the late 19th century, famous for its use in the Boer War. Almost replaced by Mausers, but the British ran out of time as WW1 began. Famous for the "Mad Minute", in which a well-trained British soldier cut put out minimum about 30 well-aimed shots at an 18-inch target 300 yards away in under a minute. In WW1 a German advance was stopped by a few British Riflemen, who used the Mad Minute, the Germans claimed they encountered Mgs. Uses a detachable 10-round magazine, and fires the .303 Enfield. A variety of different versions exist, but they are relatively the same, using the same system. Very smooth bolt action which gave it a very high rate of fire for a bolt action rifle.

Mosin-Nagant:Not a Communist weapon actually. Was adopted in the late 1800's by the Russian empire. Was used as a weapon of the Pre-Revolution Tsarist Russian Army. Many versions exist, from carbines to specialty sniper variants. Easy to zero(adjust scope to distance from target), which gave Soviet snipers an advantage. Very reliable, but very low rate of fire compared to the others. The bolt was more reliable, but was tougher to cycle. Fires 7.62x54mmR from a 5 round internal magazine.

Springfield 1903: Used by the US forces in both WW1 and WW2. Known for phenomenal accuracy, just as accurate, if not more accurate than the Mauser. Replaced the Krag-Jorgenson, which could not use stripper clips. US Marines claim they received the nickname "Devil Dogs" from the Germans in WW1, for their excellent marksmanship. Fires 30-06 Springfield from a internal 5 round mag.

MAS-36: Don't know much about this one, never fired one before. If you know about this weapon, then please inform us below. Thanks.

Carcano Series: I don't much about these either, other than one of them being used to kill JFK. I f you have any information on this fantastic weapon, please inform us below, thank you very much.

Arisaka Type 38: A fantastic weapon, used by the Imperial Army of Japan. In the beginning of the war, were very well made, but as the war continued, the production quality went down, such as using wooden butt plates, and misaligned sights. Each and every Arisaka rifle always had the imperial seal, which gave Japanese soldiers a little more confidence in their weapons.

Hanyang 88: Along with the Chiang Kai-Chek Main Battle Rifles were the primary weapon of the Chinese. Esssentially lower quality copies of German Mausers. Nothing special.
Ideas are more powerful than guns. We would not let our enemies have guns, why should we let them have ideas?
-Joseph Stalin

Last edited July 13, 2010 at 5:27 AM by EasyWay91

#40465

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

This is hands down the K98. I own a Mosin Nagant, K98, and a Lee Enfield. The Nagant has a great bark to it as well as a great punch but it doesn't impress me. The Lee Enfield can shoot all day because of its 10 round magazine, a bit heavy though. The K98 is just a pure delight. The rounded bolt handle just feels so natural when cycling in a new round. With the K98, I wonder how the Germans lost the Second World War.
"This Goddam forum smells like Volksgrenadiers!"
1st SS Division Leibstandarte SS A. H.
#40467

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Griptonix wrote:
This is hands down the K98. I own a Mosin Nagant, K98, and a Lee Enfield. The Nagant has a great bark to it as well as a great punch but it doesn't impress me. The Lee Enfield can shoot all day because of its 10 round magazine, a bit heavy though. The K98 is just a pure delight. The rounded bolt handle just feels so natural when cycling in a new round. With the K98, I wonder how the Germans lost the Second World War.

Theyve got blown up by artillery and ariforce. :D
#40472

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

For me its the Lee-Enfield. Its very hard to miss with it, and if you do do you've got 9 more rounds! The bolt was also smooth like velvet.The Kar98k was also great though. I don't really like the Mosin-Nagant though, the bolt was mot very enjoyable to work with.
Ideas are more powerful than guns. We would not let our enemies have guns, why should we let them have ideas?
-Joseph Stalin
#40527

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

First of all, I want to thank you for posting information about the rifles, and thank you for your effort.

But like everyone eles, I have to get with the K98
The Russians think there sooo tough, wait till the Ostheer comes...

Coh Name: Seeme
#40541

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

I just took the mas-36 from CoD2: Big Red One. The French Legion Enstrangers (Foreign Legion) used it, atleast in the game.
And the carcano had a 6-round clip instead of the standard 5. Otgerwise, I think it was a pretty regular gun aside from the fact it was a little crappy due the Italians' poor War Industry.
"You can close your eyes and plug your ears and be afraid and ignorant of the darker parts of history, but always know that you're the one responsible for allowing those events to happen again and with even greater consequences and not know how to end the nightmare you did upon yourself."

Last edited July 14, 2010 at 4:01 AM by HyperSniper999

#40543

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

I know most people are choosing the Kar98k. Can someone tell me why? Any actual reasons aside from just personal preference? Thanks
Ideas are more powerful than guns. We would not let our enemies have guns, why should we let them have ideas?
-Joseph Stalin
#40554

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

EasyWay91 wrote:
I know most people are choosing the Kar98k. Can someone tell me why? Any actual reasons aside from just personal preference? Thanks


Great accuracy, good rate of fire(for a bolt action), 7.92x57mm Mauser and it's the highest quality rifle of ww2
#40563

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

And it looks nice ;D
The Russians think there sooo tough, wait till the Ostheer comes...

Coh Name: Seeme
#40589

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Lee-Enfield is faster, has more rounds, and I love how the barrel is covered by wood. Not to mention the British spanned the globe with it.

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_i_9rY4P5zEk/SwPOCvQoOTI/AAAAAAAACOg/5Sn1C3wOAEk/s1600/lee-enfield_000.jpg

TOP 10:Combat Rifles - Lee Enfield No4(No.3)

But I do have to admit, I prefer the Kar98k for hunting. The Lee-Enfield wasn't made for precision but for volume of fire.
Overall Bolt-Actions are still great, kids nowadays are too enthusiastic over assault rifles.
Ideas are more powerful than guns. We would not let our enemies have guns, why should we let them have ideas?
-Joseph Stalin
#40599

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

There are no such thing about a blot action rifle these days...
The Russians think there sooo tough, wait till the Ostheer comes...

Coh Name: Seeme
#40601

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Seeme wrote:
There are no such thing about a blot action rifle these days...

I'm sure many US snipers would disagree. They still use bolt actions.
But if I were to have a gun, I'd want to it be a bolt action.
"You can close your eyes and plug your ears and be afraid and ignorant of the darker parts of history, but always know that you're the one responsible for allowing those events to happen again and with even greater consequences and not know how to end the nightmare you did upon yourself."
#40604

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

My vote goes for the lee enfield, because of it's 10 round mag.

but yeah, if i had 2 options, an AR or a bolt-action, i would also definitely choose for a bolt-action.
But yeah therefore i have to live in the US to get one legally..
and that's not the case..  :(
Forum post image
#40606

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Mosin-Nagant due to mass-production... And i'd say, it has a kick...

But when it comes to rifles, i'd perferbly choose...

1: Lever-Action [I've fired a  Winchester Model 1873]
2: Bolt-Action
3: Pump-Action
4: Automatic Rifle [Assault]
5: Semi-Automatic/Carbine [I hae these things..]
#40655

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

I wouldn't say that a lever action is better than a bolt-action. There's a reason why lever-actions weren't used in any major war, and that was because it was very hard to fire it prone. The tubular magazines also couldn't accept stripper clips, but I would still take one over an AR.

P.S. How could you not like Semi-auto carbines like the M1 or the SKS?
Ideas are more powerful than guns. We would not let our enemies have guns, why should we let them have ideas?
-Joseph Stalin
#40657

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

hmm...i don't see the point in using lever-actions in combat/live-firing exercises either, unless you're 1.) a cowboy fanatic, 2.) an unrepentant Texan who also packs a "six-gun", or 3.) an eccentric Delta sharpshooter  :P

I sometimes use my Kar98k for deer-hunting... It's a delightful rifle, reliable, substantial and accurate (even without windage adjustments or peep-sights, mind you). Sometimes I get carried away while using it, like wearing my M44 Erbsenmuster Waffen-SS camo togs with my M42 Stalhelm and pretending I'm on the Kurland front. Although I'll be shooting deer instead of Sowjiets.  ;D A rifle like that does that to you  8)
Forum post image
Wunderwaffen Doctrine: What technology created for us, we drive it towards the enemy.

Last edited July 16, 2010 at 4:54 AM by Werwolf

#40660

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

sounds very pleasant
sitting in the woods, being afraid
i guess kurland front wasnt fun anymore....
"But risk has always been an inescapable part of warfare."
Grand Admiral Thrawn
#40665

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

I tipically find my Winchester-lever action rifle easier to fire [I'm lasy, i cba moving my hand top put a new round in the rifle]  And where i come from, the only things typically you can hunt also hunt YOU! v-v.
#40723

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

mauser is my favorite :) also i like lee enfield and one more rifle which isnt included and thats vz 24 it looks like a mauser clon but it came earlier
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vz._24
#40823

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2


I sometimes use my Kar98k for deer-hunting... It's a delightful rifle, reliable, substantial and accurate (even without windage adjustments or peep-sights, mind you). Sometimes I get carried away while using it, like wearing my M44 Erbsenmuster Waffen-SS camo togs with my M42 Stalhelm and pretending I'm on the Kurland front. Although I'll be shooting deer instead of Sowjiets.  ;D A rifle like that does that to you  8)

I thought I was the only one who went out at 4 in the morning deer hunting and pretended I was hunting partisans.
[/quote]
"This Goddam forum smells like Volksgrenadiers!"
1st SS Division Leibstandarte SS A. H.
#41002

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

I am shocked - shocked - to see Kar98k winning this poll. The Lee-Enfield was by and far a superior rifle, from its inception to its used in the second World War.
#41003

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Most people dont bother learning the Lee because its Britsh, and this forum thinks britsh weapons suck.
( Besides paciet)
The Russians think there sooo tough, wait till the Ostheer comes...

Coh Name: Seeme
#41017

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Crezth wrote:
I am shocked - shocked - to see Kar98k winning this poll. The Lee-Enfield was by and far a superior rifle, from its inception to its used in the second World War.

Because the Kar looks sexier.
"You can close your eyes and plug your ears and be afraid and ignorant of the darker parts of history, but always know that you're the one responsible for allowing those events to happen again and with even greater consequences and not know how to end the nightmare you did upon yourself."
#41031

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

HyperSniper999 wrote:
Crezth wrote:
I am shocked - shocked - to see Kar98k winning this poll. The Lee-Enfield was by and far a superior rifle, from its inception to its used in the second World War.

Because the Kar looks sexier.

+1
Mors Indecepta

Might controls everything, and without strength you cannot protect anything. Let alone yourself...
#41032

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

blackbishop wrote:
HyperSniper999 wrote:
Crezth wrote:
I am shocked - shocked - to see Kar98k winning this poll. The Lee-Enfield was by and far a superior rifle, from its inception to its used in the second World War.

Because the Kar looks sexier.

+1

+2
Forum post image
Wunderwaffen Doctrine: What technology created for us, we drive it towards the enemy.
#41044

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Well I think the Kar98k looks like, well a mature, seductive beauty you would meet in a bar. The Lee-Enfield would be a more simple, adorable, and elegant woman. So basically sexy vs.cute. Lol can't believe I'm comparing 100+ year old bolt-action rifles to women.
Ideas are more powerful than guns. We would not let our enemies have guns, why should we let them have ideas?
-Joseph Stalin
#41045

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

lol!
I personally think the lee looks better..
Forum post image
#41056

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

EasyWay91 wrote:
Well I think the Kar98k looks like, well a mature, seductive beauty you would meet in a bar. The Lee-Enfield would be a more simple, adorable, and elegant woman. So basically sexy vs.cute. Lol can't believe I'm comparing 100+ year old bolt-action rifles to women.



You must be lonely...
The Russians think there sooo tough, wait till the Ostheer comes...

Coh Name: Seeme
#41070

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Well I guess that explains why Germany lost the war.
#41100

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Because they were lonely???
The Russians think there sooo tough, wait till the Ostheer comes...

Coh Name: Seeme
#41468

Re: Best Bolt Action Rifle of WW2

Seeme wrote:
Because they were lonely???

Well, Italy, Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, Croatia, Vichy France, Madagascar, Slovakia did leave them.. and japan couldn't be arsed coming round to Europe..