Vote Your TD!

Gentlemen in case you didnt know there is a tank destroyer poll opened under the General Discussion Topic

PLEASE VOTE!


Only 31 people have voted so far, I need at least  50 people to vote before declaring the winner!!



However here are the tentative winners based on the voting till now

Jagdpanther is the leader of the pack with 11 votes

Firefly is next with 4 votes 


King Tiger is the third with 3 votes

There's a tie between m26 pershing,SU 100,Panther,Geshutchwagon,Marder-3,Hetzer with 2 votes each


ISU-152 is standing with 1 vote


The rest have 0 votes


Do you think that the above result is justified??



Well here is what i think...

Seeing the above results it seems people have answered the question

"WHICH IS THE BEST SUPERHEAVY TANK"

it seems people have this uber powerful picture of a tank


The Jagdpanther is hardcapped at 1 , it can be knocked out(i have personally done so in case you don't believe) by even 2 vetted shermans , once knocked out, ruins crushed you can never get it back


then why 11 votes???

The sherman firefly  with its excellent 17 pounder deserves it place(and only because of the 17 pounder it does so,otherwise we would have seen another heavy tank here)


KING TIGER????????????

Have people lost their mind??? 

You call that turtle paced piece of rock a tank destroyer???

OMG have people really lost their sense of judgement!!

Last edited July 10, 2010 at 4:40 PM by Lord Rommel

God clam down, I have a tie between the Firefly and the pershing. I cant vote for both? So thats 1 factor.

Also why are you mad at the results? Do surveyers yell at you when they dont like the answer you picked? I agree there are some people who only like a tank because it looked cool or it had a giant gun etc, but there just people who dont know much about ww2. Cant force 'em to learn.

In my school, the best way to to write a survey is to not write any bia in it. If you dont like it, too bad. Its a survey. You cant tell them " Wrong" or " I dont like that one, pick again"

---

Post Merge: [time]1278776118[/time]

---

And also why did you lock the topic? I know it got of topic but for only like 3 post? What happen to a warning? You cant just lock something without a warning! Blah. Must have been a monday for Zerstouser.

Last edited July 10, 2010 at 3:35 PM by Seeme

Are you complaining because people vote for whatever they like?

If you send a jagdpanther alone to fight a war, it deserves to be destroyed. The same applies for any unit in CoH.

Any AT squad will do short work of any kind of sherman, vetted or not, rangers eats jagdpanthers too, what's the point of your rant?

Remember that CoH is about combining arms, not lone wolves.

AbhMkh, please refrain from using too much exclamation points, since doing such is considered to be very rude by online communities everywhere---you'd lead most people to believe that you were "shouting" all of the time.

Quite frankly, I don't see the point of this particular thread at all. People are entitled to their own opinions, and we should all respect that fact.

QuoteThe Jagdpanther is hardcapped at 1 , it can be knocked out(i have personally done so in case you don't believe) by even 2 vetted shermans , once knocked out, ruins crushed you can never get it back

Try playing PE and WH more instead of Brits. Maybe you'll get a wider perspective on using combined-arms tactics.

Last edited July 10, 2010 at 5:43 PM by Werwolf

True, you've made a similar thread. Please don't spam threads for no reason gents

Thanks for the advice werwolf,i'll keep that in mind ;D

Guys I'm sorry if i sound to be a bit rude(including the exclamation marks and my posts),but you all are intelligent men , and its true each one of us has our own opinions,but my point of conducting this survey  is to  have you guys justify your opinions,so that i can analyze and compare my understanding with yours.people have their justifications,to them whats right can be wrong to you,however i believe intellegent decisions are made only when you have a know of all the perspectives of an issue.

& I often play with wehr and PE when I'm bored of Brits and Americans and I know how to use a group of units tactically,
I was just analyzing that my conclusions about a unit are in comport with others or not.

I mean no offence gents just take it sportingly ;D


P.S : Seeme how old are you that ur still in school ;D

I rather not say becuase people tend to lose respect for me when I tell them >:(

That usually means that one is rather young and still in middle/high school. This in turn means that he has the bad luck that most people in online communities view him to be a young idiot because most of the people of his age are just that.
In seeme's case though, he is able to make good arguments which actually hold truth and such so I do not consider him to be a young idiot ;)

Cheers

Tico summoned it up pretty good :)

Well neither do I , his arguments are fine but too short :D :D

& yes as long he keeps his "High School: behavior at home, i'm cool with him ;D

Since Seeme is on a high right now from some people's opinions of him I'll refrain from posting mine :P.

Seriously AbhMkh, slow down on the posting. We do not need a million polls all over the place, nor threads that only serve to advertise for said polls. Also, just because you don't agree with someone's choice doesn't mean that it is in any way incorrect. Everyone is entitled to their opinioin. The KT is in fact an excellent tank destroyer ingame. It has nigh unbeatable armour and health and an excellent main gun. If you lose either this or the Jagd to your enemy you clearly messed up. It should be practically invincible when used properly and supported.

Well what can i say...


You just told me not to post ;D ;D

---

Post Merge: [time]1278860399[/time]

---

Well i have closed the poll and here are the official results

1. Jagdpanther

2. sherman firefly

3. King Tiger

m26 pershing,SU 100,Panther,Geshutchwagon,Marder-3,Hetzer are the runner-up's


Food For Thought?? ???

Last edited July 11, 2010 at 2:59 PM by AbhMkh

He said not to post to much and make 100s of threads.

And and quit talking about my age.

APCR Jagdpanther has the best armor penetration ingame, Firefly is second, KT is third. Not sure about ISU-152 and SU-100 but all other have less armor penetration.
x2 (and x3) Offensive veted APCR Panthers have better penetration than Fireflies.

People judge by the size of a gun. :D

I accept whatever is being said,it is pointless to argue,and seeme i just asked your age,tico posted about it first